The Role of Compound Cues in Causal Judgment: Associative and Probabilistic Effects
نویسندگان
چکیده
Contrasting associative and contingency based explanations of adult causal judgment, we derived three new predictions from the power PC theory (Cheng, 1997) concerning the role of compound cues, and we tested them in a context in which an effect could be produced by independent cues considered only as possible causes and not as enabling conditions. The first prediction, independence from the compound, was confirmed, and corroborated the theory. The second and third prediction, concerning the irrelevance of, and the equalization to a compound cue, were falsified by the experimental results. These findings suggest the existence of important factors determining causal judgements that lie beyond the scope of power PC theory.
منابع مشابه
Uncertainty and dependency in causal inference
When inferring causal relationships, people are often faced with ambiguous evidence. Models of causal inference have taken different approaches to explain reasoning about such evidence. One approach – epitomized by Bayesian models of causal inference – defers judgment by representing uncertainty across multiple explanations. Another approach – usually adopted by associative models – approximate...
متن کاملThe 28th Bartlett Memorial Lecture. Causal learning: an associative analysis.
The concordance between performance and judgements of the causal effectiveness of an instrumental action suggests that such actions are mediated by causal knowledge. Although causal learning exhibits many associative phenomena--blocking, inhibitory or preventative learning, and super-learning--judgements of the causal status of a cue can be changed retrospectively as a result of learning episod...
متن کاملThe Mechanics of Associative Change
Rescorla (in press) investigated the change in associative strength undergone by cues A and B as a result of reinforcement or nonreinforcement of an AB compound. Many leading theories of associative learning predict that if A and B are equally salient then the associative change experienced by each should be the same regardless of their associative strength preceding AB trials. Rescorla explore...
متن کاملSurprise and change: variations in the strength of present and absent cues in causal learning.
It is said that "absence makes the heart grow fonder." But, when and why does an absent event become salient to the heart or to the brain? An absent event may become salient when its nonoccurrence is surprising. Van Hamme and Wasserman (1994) found that a nonpresented but expected stimulus can actually change its associative status-and in the opposite direction from a presented stimulus. Associ...
متن کاملWithin-compound associations in retrospective revaluation and in direct learning: a challenge for comparator theory.
In three human causal learning experiments we investigated the role of within-compound associations in learning about absent cues versus learning about present cues. Different theoretical approaches agree that within-compound associations are essential for learning about absent cues-that is, for retrospective revaluation. They differ, however, with regard to the role of within-compound associat...
متن کامل